View All Articles
  • 08 December 2019
  • 4 min read

Corbyn dismisses controversy surrounding leaked NHS documents as ‘nonsense’

Subscribe To Advice

Social media platform Reddit said the papers were disclosed as ‘part of a campaign that has been reported as originating from Russia’.

Corbyn faces Reddit revelation that story was released from Russian sources

Russian story - Nonsense, says Corbyn

Jeremy Corbyn has dismissed as “nonsense” the controversy surrounding the source of leaked documents used by Labour as proof the Tories are planning to sell the NHS.

The Labour leader insisted the dossier was real after social media platform Reddit said the documents were disclosed as “part of a campaign that has been reported as originating from Russia”.

Mr Corbyn used the leaked papers as evidence that the Government was at an advanced stage of negotiations with the US to open up the health service to American pharmaceutical companies.

Find healthcare jobs

1000s of jobs for nurses, AHPs, clinicians, care assistants, managers and more. Jobs in care homes, hospitals, and the community

Find jobs

Reddit links document to suspect accounts

In a statement, Reddit said its investigation had found a “pattern of co-ordination” between the now-banned accounts on its site and a Russian campaign uncovered by Facebook earlier this year.

Information from the investigation into the “Secondary Infektion” campaign on Facebook was used to identify suspect accounts on Reddit.

Mr Corbyn was asked about the claims during a campaign visit to Barry, South Wales.

'Conspiracy theories' - Corbyn

He told reporters: “This is such nonsense. This is such an advanced stage of rather belated conspiracy theories by the Prime Minister.

Jeremy Corbyn, holding a copy of the documents at the end of November

“When we released the documents, at no stage did the Prime Minister or anybody deny that those documents were real, deny the arguments that we put forward, and if there has been no discussion with the USA about access to our health markets, if all that is wrong, how come after a week they still haven’t said that?

“The issues are that those documents show exactly what the British Government was doing in discussions with Donald Trump’s administration in the USA and also why the Prime Minister has refused to release the report on Russian interference in British politics, which he’s been sitting on for a very long time.”

He accused Boris Johnson of wanting to “hide the issues and the truth” over the future of the NHS in trade deals, adding: “We obtained those documents, we believe those documents to be correct, and nobody until yesterday had denied the correctness of those documents.

“The Prime Minister has answers to give, which he refuses to do, about Russian donations to the Tory Party or the report that he is sitting on about Russian interference in British politics.

“Of course there should be no interference in our British political system by Donald Trump or the Russians.”

Get Hired

Upload or create your CV on Our CV building tool is designed specifically for UK healthcare. Use it to apply for jobs and get hired.

Get Hired

Johnson says document does not prove anything

Speaking at a news conference last month, Mr Corbyn said the 451 pages left Mr Johnson’s claim that the NHS would not be part of trade talks “in absolute tatters”.

Reddit said the leaked files had first been posted in October and then reposted by a second account.

Pockets of accounts had worked together to “upvote” the posts using vote manipulation to make them more visible to users of the platform, it added.

“As we have done with previous influence operations, we will also preserve these accounts for a time, so that researchers and the public can scrutinise them to see for themselves how these accounts operated,” Reddit said.

Mr Johnson was asked about the dossier while visiting a Tory/Lib Dem marginal in Cheadle, near Stockport.

He said: “Well, I do think we need to get to the bottom of that. As far as I’m aware we haven’t yet established the truth about that, but what I certainly think is that document, whatever it was intended to prove, did not prove what Jeremy Corbyn and the Labour Party hoped it would prove.

“I’m afraid it was just another distraction from the void at the heart of Labour’s policy on Brexit and that still remains with five days to go until this crucial election.”

Liberal Democrat leader Jo Swinson expressed concern about claims of Russian involvement in the emergence of the documents.

She told the PA news agency: “I’m really concerned.

“All of us should be concerned if a foreign country is trying to interfere in our democracy.

“And that is why it is so appalling that the Prime Minister is sitting on a report that was written weeks before the General Election, that the Security Committee say should be published, into interference in UK democracy by foreign countries like Russia.

“He should have published that report.

“He is keeping it secret and it has to lead people to wonder what he has got to hide.”

Related stories

Corbyn claims documents reveal Tory talks on secret deal to open NHS to US firms

Johnson says claims NHS is up for grabs are in Loch Ness Monster territory

Like this article? Subscribe to The Nurses Weekly

About the author

  • Nurses news editorial team

Bringing you a daily update of nursing, NHS, health and social care news from around the UK.

Subscribe and get even more - for free

Access peer-to-peer career insights, our self-help coaching guide, plus expert videos on wellbeing, self-care and mental health


Get Hired

Use your stored CV to apply for jobs and get hired.

Get Hired